Pricing
General Pricing
Below is the general pricing for our Goodies. Specialty flavors, decor and allergen Goodies are available for an additional small fee. Please contact us to start a quote for your custom order.
Cookies
Our most popular cookies start at $10 per dozen. Gluten Free start at $15 per dozen. Same flavor per dozen.
Flavors: Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Cloud, Chocolate Macadamia, Confetti, Lemon Cloud, Orange Dream, Peanut Butter, Sugar, and more!
Cupcakes & Mini Cakes
Classic Flavors: Classic Vanilla or Chocolate with your choice of frosting: $15 per dozen
Gluten or Dairy Free: $18 per dozen
Gluten and Dairy Free: $20 per dozen
Specialty Flavors: Apple Cinnamon, Banana Pudding, Birthday Cake, Blueberry, Butter Pecan, Carrot Cake, Cassata, Chocolate, Chocolate Butterscotch chip, Caramel Toffee, Cherry Chip, Cookies and Cream, German Chocolate, Grasshopper (chocolate mint), Lemon Heaven, Orange Dreamcicle, Mint Chip, Peanut Butter Cup, Red Velvet, Real Strawberry, Turtle (chocolate caramel and pecan) with your choice of frosting.
$22 - $25 per dozen
Gluten or Dairy Free: $28 per dozen
Gluten and Dairy Free: $33 per dozen
Filled cupcakes: additional $5 per dozen. Your choice of fruit fillings or cream
Mini Cakes (Feed 1-3 ppl):
Classic Flavors: $8 each
Gluten and/or Dairy Free: $10 each
Specialty Flavors: $12 each
Gluten and or Dairy Free: $15 each
Character cupcakes require a 2 week minimum lead time.
Decor/Multiple color frosting colors available for an additional fee.
Specialty Cookies
Traditional Kolache: $30 per 100
Pecan Mini Tassies and Fruit Mini Tarts: $20 per 24
Cakecicles & Cake Pops
Cakecicles and cake pops are the hit of any party! Your choice of vanilla or chocolate cake with frosting, brownies or edible cookie dough wrapped in creamy chocolate on a stick!
Cakecicles and pops start at $25 per dozen. Contact us for a quote for your favorite character or theme!
Pies
Our pies are famous! Homemade pie crust and fillings from scratch!
Flavors: Apple Double Crust, Dutch Apple, Banana Creme, Banana Coconut, Blueberry, Blackberry, Cherry, Chocolate Creme, Coconut, Frosted Cranberry, Key Lime, Lemon, Grasshopper (Mint Chocolate), Papa's Peach, Pecan, Peanut Butter, Pumpkin, Raspberry, Strawberry, Sweet Potato, Triple Berry, Turtle (Chocolate Caramel Pecan) and more!
Crust options: Keto, Oreo, Graham Cracker or traditional pastry
Have a favorite flavor or combination? We would love to make it for you!
9” pie: $20
Gluten OR Diary free $22
Gluten AND Dairy Free: $28
Keto/Paleo: $28
Dessert Breads & Muffins
We are famous for our dessert breads!
Flavors: Gram's Apple, Banana Nut, Blackberry, Blueberry, Cinnamon Streusel, Chocolate Chunk Pound Loaf, Chocolate Chip, Lemon Pound Loaf, Lemon Poppyseed, Orange Cranberry, Papa's Peach, Pumpkin Spice, Raspberry, Sweet Orange, Strawberry, Triple Berry, Zucchini and more! Nuts optional.
Make any bread with cheesecake filling for $3.00 more.
Loaves/1 dozen muffins start at $8 each
Gluten OR Dairy Free: $10 each/per dozen
Gluten AND Dairy Free: $12 each/per dozen
Mini loaves or mini muffins also available upon request with minimum order.
Brownies, Treat Bars & Chocolates
We are famous for our treats dipped in creamy Dutch Amish chocolate, our own secret blend!
Hand dipped Oreos or pretzels: $10 per dozen Gluten Free $12 per dozen
Crispy Rice Treats: $8 per dozen
Dipped in chocolate on a stick: $15 per dozen
Brownies $8 per dozen / Gluten Free $12 per dozen
Coconut squares, Lemon Squares, Mini Cheesecakes or Mini Carrot Cakes: $20 per dozen or 24 mini
Cakes
Our Cakes come in many flavors and sizes. Gluten and/or Dairy Free Cakes are also available.
Our cakes start at $25 Please contact us to start your cake consultation.
Give Us Your Feedback
How did you enjoy your Goodie?
